Frog's Head 

Has anyone ever seen the frog's head? I have done it twice in the past and never saw it. I think there is reference to it in the Gunks Select guidebook put out by Dick Williams.

This is a good climb to link P1/P2 together for a long ~170ft lead.

The direct finish, climbing straight over the final roof instead of scrambling off left on the ledge, makes a more exciting finish to the climb. Cross the roof near an old ring piton, which fortunately can be backed up. With 60-meter rope, rap from tree back to P1 anchors. 5.6+

This is a great, well protected climb and is really fun, but very popular as well. A lot of the route is really polished, but the holds are big enough not to make much of a difference.

In reference to the first post--"Has anyone ever seen the frog's head?"

Yes, or I'm almost positive I know where it is. Located about 20-25 feet off the second pitch belay on the arete that makes up the right facing corner you climb to the right of. Look closely, and the profile of this elusive amphibian appears about midway up the arete.

great climb, good variety of moves.

Just did the first pitch of Frog's Head, traversed left at bolts to the other set of bolts, and did second pitch of City Lights. Made for a fantastic climb.

P1: Pretty fun, a few short crack moves.

P2: Only thing I didn't like was having to trust a pin right off of the belay, didn't see a way to back it up. But there were jugs pretty much all the way up, some good steep-ish sections, plenty of pro, very fun pitch. I went all the way to the top and my second couldn't hear me yelling from there, if you have walkies use them. Also, if you go all the way to the top, you miss an easy rappel station on the ledge before the very top off to the right.

Got on this past Saturday and got some nice beta from locals. You can finish the second pitch by pulling the roof (very chill). After that there's 10' of easy slab and a tree anchor with webbing and rap rings. Very awesome way to finish a great climb.

P2: My first pro was a #2 Camalot just below that fixed pin. Somehow I didn't perceive a "thin crack" after the first 20 ft of P2. I did see a shallow right-facing corner which sort of led up to the big overhanging right-facing corner -- and climbing up somewhere near that shallow corner seemed to work.

Polished? Overall it did not strike me that the rock was notably polished from grit on climbers' shoes (as often does happen to footholds in softer rock like limestone, which can get seriously slippery after they've gotten lots of dirty-shoes climber traffic).
Maybe some of the rock on Frog's Head has a higher quartz content and lower percent of embedded pebbles + granules than most Gunks routes (perhaps this is why the base section of Frog's Head has a lighter color) so some footholds might have less friction than others in the Gunks. But although I remember a shortage of obvious footholds around the P1 crux, when I did find the non-obvious smaller ones and then tried standing on them, their friction supported my foot just fine - no slipping off.