Evil Alchemist 

I bolted this route after climbing the Evil Elliot route to the left. At the time we thought it was about 13a. Matt Samet made the first ascent of this one on his first trip to the dungeon and agreed on the grade, but he didn't use any knee bars.

I'll second Luke's opinion on the rating. 12c, hummmm..... Who's the consensus?

Regarding the grade and the beta, I used what seemed like an obvious kneebar on my right leg to turn the "lip" of the bottom steep section which made a desparately powerful move for me something that I could almost no-hands in the middle of with the kneebar. With this beta the route went down 2nd try for me at a time when I was truly maxed climbing at .12+ leading me to believe that .13a couldn't be accurate.

I am certain that this route would feel much harder than .12c without this beta although I never did try to repeat it either way.

As Matt states, I recall making important use of a kneebar below the roof; this definitely made the clip at the lip and the move out of the roof reasonable. That said, I always thought that the crux was the move that is shown in the picture above, i.e. a few moves above the roof. The body tension required for that move made me want to fill my Huggies. I have not been on this in years, but I remember both my partner and I agreeing that this was definitely 13a. Just my 2 cents.