A classic line that is rated V3 in all the guidebooks but feels at least V4 to me, oh well, ratings smatings. Start on the center left of the wall on some jugs. Throw a heel in an obvious jug and move with the right hand up and into a shallow three finger pocket, mantle onto your left foot and pinch two dicey pebbles to reach the top.
V3 my ass! In contrast to the other Red Wall boulder problems, this one favors short people. The mantle move is super scrunchy. If you are tall and/or inflexible and/or not good with pockets, this classic could give you more trouble than some Vhard rated problems.
Pat Ament called Center Left B5.10 in the Third Edition of High Over Boulder, which usually equates to V2 or V3. That said, his descriptions over the years in High Over Boulder suggest one starts with their right hand high up in the shallow pocket. As everyone knows, Philip Benningfield's modus operandi is to never uprate problems. The lowest rating he ever hears out of anyone's mouth is what you will see in his books and that is the grade you usually hear sprayed out at the boulders.
IMHO, starting even that high is still V3/4 as the next move to the crystal pinch is pretty clutch. Starting lower is most definitely harder as you have to do all that footwork and then the very long move holding almost all your body on that shallow right hand. I suggest V5 for the lower start that almost everyone these days tries to do. This one is just a tad easier than Varney Direct, which I feel approaches V6, but that's a whole nuther issue.
In any event, one of five 3 star problems on this boulder's west face (Center Left, Standard Route, Red Wall Direct, Moffat Direct and Right Side) ... one of the highest concentrations of 3 star problems anywhere. Of course, that's my opinion and there are those who hold Flag in lesser regard.
To them, I say ... "that's like your opinion dude."
I'd have to agree on the whole height thing here. At 5'9" this problem is doable for me more times than not; whereas the right problem is doable much fewer times.
Make sure you have a spotter and a crash pad when you reach up for the crystal. I didn't and landed right on my heel, I think I cracked the bone. Anyways, Center Left doesn't play well those that are 6 ft tall. It may have been V3 back before the crowds and erosion, but I think it's closer to V4.
Every time I get on this problem I feel so close; but alas, it always eludes me. I have never projected a V3 for so long... it puts a smile on my face. -You ridiculous V3... I WILL stand on top and look down upon you!
There's a smaller two-finger pocket just down and left of the good one. I get my left in that (after getting the right), flip my right heel to a toe, and bring my left foot up to the starting hold/jug to stand up for the pinch. To me, it feels better than doing a foot-to-hand match.