Home - Destinations - People - Partners - Forum - Photos - What's New
 ADVANCED
Black DIamond gear (protection) made in china??????

  [ Forums > Climbing Gear Discussion ]
Sponsored by
Spadout.com
 
View Latest Posts in this Forum     Page 5 of 10.  <Prev  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next>

 
By Tony Bubb
From Boulder, CO
Aug 29, 2007
A less frequently shot view of Devil's Tower, just after the clearing of a summer storm. Photo by Tony Bubb, 7/01.

Mark Nelson wrote:
John, I gotta tell ya, I wish we had more. We're talking about dealing with terrorists, not U.S. citizens. Frankly, I'd like see those assholes in Guantanamo lined up in front of wall and shot.


That demonstrates a gross misunderstanding of who is there. Mark, your posts always seem to have some sense to them, but this one actually frightens me. Yes, I am actually FRIGHTENED by that thought. I doubt you have any or all of the evidence to try any of them... Yes, there are no doubt SOME very bad people there. But there are some that do not deserve what they are getting.

Perhaps you should read a little more about some of the people that have been held there (and eventually released, or not yet.). You might want to start by reading about it from the ACLU. For what it is worth, I spent 2 hours with one of the lawyers volunteering for the ACLU to represent some of the Gitmo cases. They are obscene.
They are not US citizens, they are, however, humans.
The Declaration of Independance put forth the philosophy of the founders of this nation. They didn't care who you were or what nation you came from- they stated that there are basic rights as humans that a nation must respect.

Isn't your proposal akin to turning over any of our soldiers to the Iraqi's or Afgani's and letting them use their systems to try our guys if they are accused of wrong doing?

By Shawn Shannon
From Denver, CO
Aug 29, 2007
Myself

BrettPierce wrote:
What is wrong with pointing out areas in which the US can improve? Is it more American to pretend that we are perfect? It seems that if anyone doesn't agree with you, then they are not patriotic Americans.


Criticism isn't a problem, but people can disagree as well.

Actually, the main thing I think sets people off (including myself) is when people compare the US to Stalin, Apartheid, and the worst racism.

Currently compared to any country I'd rather be a minority in the US than anywhere else (I'm Irish, so I'm only a minority in Denver). Even places like France, Germany, Britain continue to have regular voilent racist riots. We have more freedom here than anywhere (except 3rd world where there's no laws), or else there wouldn't be such a debate. The socialists (Stalin (history)/Castro (current)/Chavez (new)...) just had outright firing squads against dissidents, outright took people's property and titles.
We DEFINITELY have room for improvement. We ALWAYS will, as we get better. We have always been a generous nation, but have learned our generousity isn't always done right. Just because we could've done something better in hindsight doesn't make us bad.

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Tony Bubb wrote:
Yes, there are no doubt SOME very bad people there. But there are some that do not deserve what they are getting.


Agreed, my context is a generalized statement from someone sick & tired of catering to terrorists.

Isn't your proposal akin to turning over any of our soldiers to the Iraqi's or Afgani's and letting them use their systems to try our guys if they are accused of wrong doing?

No, you can't correlate professional soldiers serving the U.S. to terrorists; our professional soldiers are bound by a military code of conduct & Geneva Convention, along with NATO & UN treaty.

By Charlie Perry
From Fort Collins
Aug 29, 2007

I always liked Lennon and Marx. John Lennon wrote some purty songs, and groucho was funny. What I really find hilarious is that one of Amercias big chants is to "Stop the Spread of Communism" and most of what we buy is manufactured in a communist county. Americans are the least informed most entertained people in the world. Fifty percent of us cannot get out of our indented couch's to go vote! I guess this 50% is watching Oprah. What's worse is that we do not even care about each other. I could be myopic in this statement. Corporations use to put their workers welfare first. Now it seems many corporations will throw anyone under the bus for a buck. I know this has happened at HP. Most of my neighbors work there and this is their sentiments. It seems like our country's moral stance is either abortion or gay marriage and ethics like in climbing, can be assigned to bar stools. What about some morals towards each other. How about some ethics in business. It seems that pure capitalism is not working as well as the founding fathers planned. Exxon made how many billions of dollars last quarter? Enron took the money and ran. Even our Attorney General is corrupt. It will be interesting to see what becomes of our country.

Gee I feel better!

The only thing I can say about BD going to China is that if one of their pieces made in China ever fails due to an manufacturing error, they might as well close the doors to their gear division. It seems that no one is really sure they are even making this move and look at all the hubbub. Think what the witch hunt will be like if a piece fails.

Have a nice day everyone.

By BrettPierce
From Colorado Springs
Aug 29, 2007
ice

Shawn Shannon wrote:
Just because we could've done something better in hindsight doesn't make us bad.


Your are right, but it does mean that we should learn from our mistakes.

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Charlie Perry wrote:
... How about some ethics in business.


I think this is more to the point about what's going on. Is it a bad ethic to work within other countries or to work with others from different countries?

We're working within Costa Rica, Mexico, Turkey, Japan, Vietnam & many others. I think John Glime has some great insight from his travels as to corporate moral responsibility.

I think it depends on the situation.

By Ben F
From Benfield, Kolorado
Aug 29, 2007

Kevin Stricker wrote:
Don't you think the primary human right is for food and shelter?


You're confusing "right" with "need."

By Daniel Crescenzo
From Wrongmont, CO
Aug 29, 2007
Crux?

Man, everyone is an armchair expert on business ethics in country and out. Ethics are in the eye of the management. If the company is run by bad people the ethics of that business will be as lousy as legally possible (if not worse). If the company is run by good people the ethics will be better. The locale of the business is trivial! It's the ownership/management that makes it good or bad. Slash and burn business ethics exist here, there, and everywhere. Just b/c a society has affluence doesn't necessarily mean it has a conscience (I have worked for some lousy folks in this country), it just means they are better at portraying it.

By cameron
Aug 29, 2007

Bubb - Spending a few hours with an ACLU attorney made you an expert on who is at Gitmo, what there history and intentions were/are? If there was a group out there whose ethics are questionable, it'd be the ACLU.

Ethics in business. . . the point exactly.

By Tea
Aug 29, 2007
step aside puny human.

Gettin a bit thick in here.

By Mike McHugh
From Denver, CO
Aug 29, 2007
I wish this was me.

This is all too frustrating and confusing! If I buy a BD cam now, I guess I'm supporting islamo-fascist, neoconservative, human-rights abusing commies!

I'm going back to my good old Lowe Alpine Systems cams:

By Mike McHugh
From Denver, CO
Aug 29, 2007
I wish this was me.

BTW - tea, you're on my heroes list. seriously.

By Tony Bubb
From Boulder, CO
Aug 29, 2007
A less frequently shot view of Devil's Tower, just after the clearing of a summer storm. Photo by Tony Bubb, 7/01.

cameron wrote:
Bubb - Spending a few hours with an ACLU attorney made you an expert on who is at Gitmo, what there history and intentions were/are? If there was a group out there whose ethics are questionable, it'd be the ACLU. Ethics in business. . . the point exactly.


I suspect that means I have ~2 hours more background info more than the average guy. I read plenty too. I've read court documents and congressional reports on rendition victims as well. You know, the ones where congress says they were kidnapped, tortured, and held for months without change, and were eventually cleared of wrong doing?

Google these:
"Bisher al-Rawi" + rendition + innocent
"Mohamed Farag Ahmad Bashmilah" + rendition + innocent
"Khaled El-Masri" + rendition + innocent

Ask me why we are going to Britain, Jordon, Germany, etc... kidnapping their citizens or visitors, dressing them in diapers and photographing them, beating them, flying them to Afganistan, Syria, etc... torturing them, holding them for 6 moths, then setting them free, naked on a hillside with no ID. Or in Al-Rawi's case, kept in Gitmo for 4 years before being released without charges.

Line that up against a wall and shoot it!
Admittedly, in China they already would have...

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

I guess maybe the A in ACLU has lost it's meaning? I think not.

They are in existence for the protection of our civil rights. To translate that into providing the world's terrorists with legal representation, I don't get that. I understand the necessity of: if this administration does this, then they could do the same to its citizens. So, as to safegaurd our rights, the ACLU is quite necessary in the happenings at Gitmo. Fine with me.

Let's move forward in the legal process then, or set them free. Which part of Boulder can we drop them off at?

By Jeff Fiedler
Aug 29, 2007

Cameron: Not sure you actually read my post before responding?

"Fiedler - Again, I don't care about China. . . I care about America."
- My post was exactly about what is good for the US; I didn't say much at all about what would help China.

"This conversation has become convoluted due to some trying to make this into an issue whose context isn't important. HISTORY and POLICY and which country is the most horrific."
- I agree, and didn't address that. (My own 2 cents: A lot of home-grown and foreign criticism of the US is inane. But in the past and present the US hasn't always done things we can be proud of. I'd still much rather live here than any where else, for the rule of law, personal protections, and mix of idealism and pragmatism.)

"Try to stick with the issue here - BD has sent its homegrown facilities to China to save a few dollars for their personal fuckin salaries!"
- I just think your view here is really really simplistic, as I tried to point out. For the sake of argument, lets say you are right and it hurts the US to import products made overseas: So what is your solution? Ban foreign-made products? That just causes more harm than good in the long run.

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Kevin Craig wrote:
Ha ha! Mark, you clearly have not been paying much attention to current events for some years now (not that I blame you!) Very disappointing in general. ... I am seriously going to have to reconsider my pre-order of a set of the new Cobras if, as stated, they're being assembled in China. :^(((



Well, I am credited with being very slow. sorry, missed your post this morning.

I guess you could always switch to Grivel and be a real climber!

By Matt Nelson
From Honolulu, HI
Aug 29, 2007
Tetons again...

Mark Nelson wrote:
John, I gotta tell ya, I wish we had more. We're talking about dealing with terrorists, not U.S. citizens. Frankly, I'd like see those assholes in Guantanamo lined up in front of wall and shot.


Hell yea bro. I would definitely agree with that...

By Tavis Ricksecker
From flagstaff, az
Aug 29, 2007
Wednesday night, performing at the Lady Sassafras art car while DJ Treavor of Moontribe lays down some crunchy techno

Mark Nelson wrote:
No, you can't correlate professional soldiers serving the U.S. to terrorists; our professional soldiers are bound by a military code of conduct & Geneva Convention, along with NATO & UN treaty.


...which they obviously always follow, right? So if you're a soldier (terrorist) not specifically employed by a country, you should be shot? And how about the paramilitaries in Columbia on the payroll of U.S. based corporations? Why is nobody rounding them up and shooting them for killing and terrorizing their own citizens? Oh, right... because they're working for us.

I don't hate the U.S. I just hate foreign policy that gets innocent people killed. And I hate the hypocrisy that passes for patriotism these days. Terrorism is terrorism, regardless of under what premise it is committed. Just as a sweatshop is a sweatshop, regardless of what country it lies in.

Instead of focusing our hatred on the 'commies' and the Islamic terrorists, we should be working for the betterment of all people. That has clearly not been the agenda of the U.S. up to this point, and it is up to us to change that.

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Tavis Ricksecker wrote:
...which they obviously always follow, right?


No, but they are held to account.

By John J. Glime
From Salt Lake City, UT
Aug 29, 2007

Most soldiers get put to trial in a sham military court and do NOT recieve anything like real punishment. They are put on trial by peers who are sympathetic to their plight. Military courts are a JOKE.

But, when the U.S. government wants even dirtier stuff done, they hire out to war contractors. Whom, when killed or caught do not officially represent the U.S.

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Tavis Ricksecker wrote:
Instead of focusing our hatred on ... the Islamic terrorists, we should be working for the betterment of all people. That has clearly not been the agenda of the U.S. up to this point, and it is up to us to change that.


You're right, it's not. Terrorists don't care about the betterment of their fellow man or anyone else for that matter.

It's clearly up to us to pull our head out of our butts and realize that our foreign policy is way off course, our leadership is weak as hell, and our citizens are under attack & get it through our heads, we are at war.

Telling everyone to accept peace without being able to stand up to account for it doesn't do us a bit of good when some jackass straps a bomb to his chest and tries to obliterate his fellow man.

I have no problem working toward peace, let's make it happen.

By John J. Glime
From Salt Lake City, UT
Aug 29, 2007

The thing that gets me is because some of us are critical of our government, you right wing nut jobs (generalization) want to say that we hate America! Apples and oranges folks. But if it makes you feel better...

In regards to Guantanamo for those whom haven't heard it: http://www.thislife.org/Radio_Episode.aspx?sched=1123

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Hopefully, I'm not trying to get you to that impression. I know we all care about this country. We just have different ways of expressing it. (Dang, John I want to be the rwnj, frankly I liked being the rw co-conspirator back in the day)

The problem is the apathy, which I must say for some really great reason, climbers clearly lack this attribute of our society.

By Tavis Ricksecker
From flagstaff, az
Aug 29, 2007
Wednesday night, performing at the Lady Sassafras art car while DJ Treavor of Moontribe lays down some crunchy techno

Mark Nelson wrote:
You're right, it's not. Terrorists don't care about the betterment of their fellow man or anyone else for that matter. It's clearly up to us to pull our head out of our butts and realize that our foreign policy is way off course, our leadership is weak as hell, and our citizens are under attack. Get it through your head, we are at war. Telling everyone to accept peace without being able to stand up to account for it doesn't do us a bit of good when some jackass straps a bomb to his chest and tries to obliterate his fellow man.


You have a good point, but none of us have the solution to that situation, yet. Still, you ignore the fact that the U.S. government and U.S. based corporations have in the past and still do employ terrorists for their own aims as well. And we could argue about U.S. foreign policy and whether the current policy has hindered or helped the aims of the Islamic terrorists.

But this discussion wasn't about terrorism, it was about a U.S. company exporting its manufacturing to a country that has gross violations of human rights, specifically because it would be cheaper to manufacture their goods there and they could make more profit. This is a practice which many U.S. companies share, whether it's exporting manufacturing to the Phillipines or to Mexico, or whether it's displacing native people from their land in order to extract resources like in Indonesia and Ecuador.

We could go on and on about this all day, and no one is going to change their political views.

Kudos and respect to everyone who has participated in this discussion who thinks about where the products that they buy are coming from. I encourage you all to continue to do this! Don't just research and think about BD and China. Research Chiquita Banana and Coca Cola in Columbia. Research Shell Oil in Ecuador. Research the maquiladoras and sweatshops in Mexico and the Phillipines. This type of thing is happening every day in countries all over the world. It would be very narrow thinking to boycott BD cams and continue to purchase products manufactured or extracted from other countries which also violate the rights of their people.

No one seems to want to respond to any of the specific examples I've cited, so I'm done with this discussion. I do hope we all think more about this issue. It's not just going to go away.

-Tavis

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Aug 29, 2007
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Tavis, sorry I edited some stuff, hope it didn't change some context.


  [ Forums > Climbing Gear Discussion ]
Page 5 of 10.  <Prev  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next>