Home - Destinations - People - Partners - Forum - Photos - What's New
 ADVANCED
BD vs Metolius Hexes

  [ Forums > Climbing Gear Discussion ]
Sponsored by
Spadout.com
 
View Latest Posts in this Forum     Page 1 of 2.  1  2  Next>

 
By Jason Isherwood
From d met co
May 6, 2008

Hey,

I am pretty new to the site and relatively new to leading. My modest rack currently consists of C4's (0.75-3) as well as a full set of DMM wallnuts. Right now I am contemplating a set of hexes. I was hoping to get some feedback on what people prefer, Black Diamond's Wired Hexes or Metolius Curved Hexes? I don't have any experience placing curved hexes , however, I like the curve hex design and am seriously contemplating a set of them over BD. Thanks in advance for any feedback.

By Jon Leicht
From Santee, CA
May 6, 2008
Me in the winter

I know you asked specifically about the wired hexes, but I am a big fan of the Wild Country Chocks. They are slung with slings eliminating the need for draws. While the wires do have their own positives I have found the WC hexes way easier to deal with.

By James Beissel
From Boulder, CO
May 6, 2008
Ghostride da whip!

Buy the three largest Wild Country hexes and save the rest of your money for more cams.

By John Langston
May 6, 2008

If you've got up to a #3 camalot, you really don't need hexes. Or rarely anyway.

Get a single BD#11 and you'll use it twice in the next year then give it to one of your friends.

Don't buy a set, it's a waste.

By Darren Mabe
From Goulder, CO
May 6, 2008
some day, some where, together in Indian Creek

i say, shit-can your #12 and #13 stoppers, and carry only #5,6,7 hexes.

By Peter Kananen
From Cincinnati, OH
May 6, 2008
rrg

I'm a fan of the Metolius curve hexes myself, but I've only placed the 3 or 4 largest ones. I think those are useful. Other than that, cams. Don't need the smaller ones IMO. You can get 4 for around the price of one cam, and sometimes they can be used where a cam won't work.

By Jason Isherwood
From d met co
May 6, 2008

So it sound's like you guys think a full set would be a waste...what about this:

http://www.backcountry.com/store/MET0207/Metolius-Curve-Hex->>>>>

Or is that even overkill...should I just save my green for cams, booze and hookers?

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
May 6, 2008
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

The trouble with climbers these days is there simply isn't enough cowbell.


I'm a Metolius man.

By John Langston
May 6, 2008

Jason Isherwood wrote:
should I just save my green for cams, booze and hookers?


I always like to bet on the sure thing

By Ernie Rolls
From Custer, SD
May 6, 2008
Devils Tower Summit

James Beissel wrote:
Buy the three largest Wild Country hexes and save the rest of your money for more cams.


Good advice if you prefer cams.

I have a full set of curved hexes and love them. I use them all.
They seem to wiggle right in a tight placement where a BD just fights you.

WC's are probably the favorite of many even though many folks hate hexes. I think this is because they do take some thought/time to place properly. IMO, when you get that bomber hex of any size, nothin else will fit quite as well.

-E

By Avery Nelson
From Boulder, CO
May 6, 2008
Avery, 300' up Japanese Coulior

Alpine: Hexes in the BD Equivalent size 6-9 seem to be the most versatile, because the range covered by setting them camming or sideways seems to cover the broadest common-use range (.75-3 BD Cam size). Smaller sizes are typically covered by large stoppers or small tri-cams or cams (which are actually relatively light). Larger sizes aren't often needed on alpine routes.

I would avoid wired hexes.

By Aaron Martinuzzi
From Fort Collins, CO
May 6, 2008
boulder project in muir valley near the boneyard<br />

i'm a fairly new leader as well, and what leading i've done has been on wallnuts, BD hexes, and some camalots and friends. cams are wonderfully easy, but i've found it really pays to toss a hex in if you can, thus saving your cams for later on in the route when you might be more pumped or wigged out. this applies doubly on more sustained cracks, where hexes make for a light, cheap, bomber alternative to carrying several of the same or similar size cams.

that said, i have noticed that the angular BD hexes do sort of fight placement when placed with their length parallel to the crack. i haven't used the WC rockcentrics or Metolius Curved Hexes, but as i consider buying gear i'm leaning toward the WC's. i like the fact that they're on dyneema instead of wire, and the metolius ones sort of scare me with all those curves.

By Not So Famous Old Dude
From Denver, CO
May 6, 2008

Jason Isherwood wrote:
So it sound's like you guys think a full set would be a waste...what about this: http://www.backcountry.com/store/MET0207/Metolius-Curve-Hex->>>>> Or is that even overkill...should I just save my green for cams, booze and hookers?


Sounds like you aren't already sold on the hex idea. Good, because hexes are really old school. I'd say skip the hexes altogether and use the money to buy doubles of cams. My hexes sit at the bottom of my gear closet now and have since the day I doubled my my cams. Good for bail gear or aid possibly, but I don't ever carry them even for that, anymore. Hexes are just a footnote in climbing history for practical applications these days.

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
May 6, 2008
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Don't you guys know about the hex toss grapple hook method??? Geeze, you all take the fun out of gear.

I think we should ban all cams; a no cam park.

By Larry DeAngelo
Administrator
May 6, 2008
!

I'm a big fan of hexes, and prefer the 70 style: straight (no curve, no taper), slung about 18 inches on perlon. In conventional hexes I don't usually have anything other than #6 up to #9 (old Chouinard #6 is about 1x1.5", #9 is 2x2.5")-- unless I'm doing a "hexes-only" day.

I always cover the half-inch to one-inch range with hexes also-- just not the conventional type. I carry the long-discontinued Doltnuts on over-the-shoulder slings, and don't bother with stoppers unless they are real thin. See this Photo for example.

By Jason Isherwood
From d met co
May 6, 2008

Aaron Martinuzzi wrote:
the metolius ones sort of scare me with all those curves.


I feel the same way. I know they are "old school", however, in my experience I have found that they seem to fit my style of climbing. Call me crazy. I have placed "regular" hexes a fair amount during my limited leading experiences. Most of this climbing has been around the Flatirons and Eldo. I find them very useful and can really see myself placing them frequently off of my personal rack. After reading the responses I think I will forgo the full set and get larger sizes. I don't know why I am apprehensive to go with the curved ones, but for some reason I am. With that being said, I might just bite the bullet and get the Metolius Alpine set, I am sure I will grow to love them. It seems as though they will suit my needs the best.

Avery, is there any particular reason you would avoid a wired set?

Thanks for all the responses.

By Larry DeAngelo
Administrator
May 6, 2008
!

Jason Isherwood wrote:
is there any particular reason you would avoid a wired set?


On a long, flexible sling, you can avoid carrying an extra runner and carabiner. Sometimes you can get a very satisfying "out of reach" placement with an over-the-head swing. See, for example, the aptly named Lucky Nuts.

By Not So Famous Old Dude
From Denver, CO
May 6, 2008

I just noticed your BD cam sizes. If you don't have any smaller cams yet (TCUs/Aliens, etc.) then I would definitely not waste one dime on hexes until I acquired at least two small camming units.

By Jason Isherwood
From d met co
May 6, 2008

Smaller cams are on the agenda as well. Once again, I am split between BD and Metolius. I have messed around with the new Master Cams a little and was quite impressed. However, C3s are pretty sweet as well...

By Doug Hemken
From Madison, WI
May 6, 2008
At the crux of McCarthy West Face var

When I was young (in high school) and poor, our standard rack was: a set of nuts, a set of hexes (straight-sided), and maybe 4 cams.

Now that I'm old and averse to carrying heavy weights, my standard rack is: a set of nuts, a set of cams, and maybe 4 hexes. Unless you are climbing a long crack that you know to be unrelentingly parallel or flaring, using hexes will save you weight.

On easy routes I often revert to my high school rack, especially if I'm heading up into the backcountry.

I like curved nuts but straight hexes. I also prefer slinging my own hexes with perlon or tech cord.

By Darren Mabe
From Goulder, CO
May 6, 2008
some day, some where, together in Indian Creek

Mark Nelson wrote:
isn't enough cowbell.


LOL!!!!!

we definately need more cowbell.

By Darren Mabe
From Goulder, CO
May 6, 2008
some day, some where, together in Indian Creek

regarding size #5-7, they make good lightweight belay pieces, so you dont have to burn precious McDonald's cams (BD #1 and #2) at a belay...

about the only reason i rack those hexes, other than for nostalgia.

By Charles Danforth
From L'ville, CO
May 6, 2008
Do a little dance...

Hey, there's no school like the old school! There is absolutely nothing more bomber than a well-placed hex and I'd rather take a whipper that than anything else. These days I carry BD #5-9 or so, occasionally the bigger stuff, as well as a full set of stoppers and BD Cams #.3-3. Haven't tried the curved hexes myself, but I can see where they might be handy.

By Jason Isherwood
From d met co
May 6, 2008

Darren Mabe wrote:
we definately need more cowbell.


Isn't that true in every aspect of life...

By Peter Kananen
From Cincinnati, OH
May 6, 2008
rrg

Jason Isherwood wrote:
I feel the same way. I know they are "old school", however, in my experience I have found that they seem to fit my style of climbing. Call me crazy. I have placed "regular" hexes a fair amount during my limited leading experiences. Most of this climbing has been around the Flatirons and Eldo. I find them very useful and can really see myself placing them frequently off of my personal rack. After reading the responses I think I will forgo the full set and get larger sizes. I don't know why I am apprehensive to go with the curved ones, but for some reason I am. With that being said, I might just bite the bullet and get the Metolius Alpine set, I am sure I will grow to love them. It seems as though they will suit my needs the best. Avery, is there any particular reason you would avoid a wired set? Thanks for all the responses.


When comparing straight versus curved, I found curved much more versatile. They're just as bomber, too.

By Paul Hunnicutt
From Boulder, CO
May 6, 2008
Half Dome

I love to place a bomber hex. However, my main problem is that no one else I climb with wants to place them. So they end up being a bit of a waste on most adventures. I guess I would feel the same if someone brought tri-cams.

I can say BD hexes when placed well are so utterly perfect you almost want to climb up 30 feet and lob off just to test it. Not that I'm into that, but I'll take a good hex over anything else. I usually carry 3 or 4 of the mid-sized ones (6,7,8, or 9) if I carry them at all. The big size get very bulky and I don't find placements as often (kind of like the "should we bring the #4 cam" debate) and you might as well just use nuts for the small ones.

They are great at belays, save weight instead of doubling up on cams. I typically bring them for more moderate alpine climbing. If it gets hard for me I'd rather have a bit more weight with more cams, but be able to quickly fire in more gear....sorry not at all answering the question about curved as I've never used them.


  [ Forums > Climbing Gear Discussion ]
Page 1 of 2.  1  2  Next>