Home - Destinations - iPhone/Android - Gyms - Partners - Forum - Photos - Deals - What's New
 ADVANCED
Catskills / bard college



View Latest Posts in This Forum or All Forums


Page 1 of 1.  
 
By Medic741
From Pittsford, New York
Dec 25, 2012
When I was a bum at Frey

Hello all, I am considering attending bard in Annendale. Any beta on mountain biking, hiking, climbing in the Catskills/ surrounding area?

Any insider thoughts on the school or what it's like living in the area? Any comments are appreciated.

Matt


FLAG
By Jon H
From Northern NJ
Dec 25, 2012
Modica-Noury SuperGoullotte.  Mont Blanc De Tacul, Chamonix. TD+

The only climbing to speak of in the Catskills itself is ice climbing. The rock is decomposing chossy shale and worthless in the summer. Luckily, you're smack dab in the middle between the Gunks and the Dacks.

Tons of hiking and backcountry adventures to be had.

No idea about the mountain biking, but I suspect it's pretty damn good and there's tons of it.

PS - It's "Annandale"


FLAG
By Medic741
From Pittsford, New York
Dec 25, 2012
When I was a bum at Frey

Thanks Jon! Ill remember that from now on. The location of the place definitely looks pretty prime.


FLAG
By Wormly81
Dec 25, 2012

Less than an hour from the Gunks is a pretty good deal. The catskills have some great ice climbing although the season can be a little short as of recently. There is good hiking in the Catskill park for those days you need to get some fresh air and put some mileage under your feet. The Adirondacks have both incredible ice climbing, rock climbing, and hiking but its a little less than 3 hours into Keene. There is some recently developed Adirondack rock climbing closer than that too. All in all, eastern NY is a great place to climb if you have a car and gas money.


FLAG
By Adam Paashaus
From North Carolina
Dec 25, 2012
After you get done climbing be sure to head up to the summit for sunset. Its only a 10 minute walk from the main wall. Don't forget your headlamp.

I grew up in the Catskills and they are still one of my favorite areas anywhere. They are unlike any mountain area in the east and the differences might be subtle but since they are not the Appalachians they are geologically unique. The hiking is excellent and the towns are more like hamlets. I bet more than 20 "towns" all go to the same high school! I like the small town feel. Phonecia's sweet sues is a great place to get breakfast and I just noticed that there is a small sport crag there. Never been so who knows the quality but generally, yes, the rock sucks. I find the area to be magical but maybe spending to much time in Woodstock as a teenager has made me a little biased ;) Lots of cool swimming holes.


FLAG
By Medic741
From Pittsford, New York
Dec 25, 2012
When I was a bum at Frey

Awesome! Getting excited to go visit :D


FLAG
By Gunkiemike
Dec 26, 2012

Adam's pretty proud of the Catskills, but Bard isn't in the Catskills. It's across the river, and the vibe is distinctly different there. Here's my 2 cents. First of all, you need to understand that Bard is one of the most liberal colleges in NY. Think "Walden" from the Doonesbury comic strip. Liberal means tolerance, of course, but if you lean toward the right on any major issue, you'll probably need to keep that in the closet.

Bard is just a few minutes north of Rhinebeck NY, an artsy, antiquey village with bad traffic every summer weekend. It is also home to the county fairgrounds, and there are a few major events each season when you'll want to stay away from town. The county fair itself draws something like 200,000 attendees. 20 minutes south puts you in Poughkeepsie, home to all the malls and big box stores you'll need. Not sure, but the county bus system probably runs that way. On that note, public transportation is not well developed in the area. If you have off-campus interests, you'll want access to a car.

As noted, the Gunks are a short drive away. Downhill skiing is less than an hour away.


FLAG
By Kevin Heckeler
From West Sand Lake, New York
Dec 26, 2012
Rumney

Gunkiemike wrote:
...if you lean toward the right on any major issue, you'll probably need to keep that in the closet.


Considering how far right the Right are at the moment (and how detached from reality the political right are), I'd see it as an opportunity to re-evaulate the position taken rather than feel "oppressed" for having it.

Can't fix stupid, but we can cure ignorance.

Most non-urban areas in Upstate NY are "red" (Republican). This isn't news. Only a handful of hippy towns (Woodstock, etc) are progressive / liberal. That's why they're note worthy. Hence why Mike is making the distinction here.

I wouldn't consider this much of an issue unless you're running for political office or plan on mingling with the locals a lot. I live in a county that's 90% red and I'm rather liberal (in comparison). I know none of my neighbors. Not on purpose, just have no reason to. The internet is great for making friends from anywhere, so I find where I lay my head doesn't matter much. So don't feel limited by your geographic/demographic surroundings. if you like the college then go for it. Plenty of climbing an hour south at the Gunks, 1.5+ hours north in the ADKs. Tons of people doing outdoors stuff from all walks and personal philosophies of life to choose from. Heck, I even find the company of Republicans entertaining from time to time. lol


FLAG
By rgold
From Poughkeepsie, NY
Dec 26, 2012
The traverse out to the Yellow Ridge on the Dogstick Ridge link-up.  Photo by Myriam Bouchard

Gunkiemike wrote:
First of all, you need to understand that Bard is one of the most liberal colleges in NY. Think "Walden" from the Doonesbury comic strip.


Comparing Bard to Doonsbury's Walden is exceptionally far off the mark. Walden is a third-rate institution with ever-declining academic standards and a student body whose interest in any part of the academic enterprise is non-existent. Moreover, is Walden isn't recognizably liberal; the students are characterized by apathy if not ignorance of societal issues, not by any kind of engagement in causes beyond the preservation of keggers.

Bard, on the other hand, is among the most academically intense institutions out there. Not in terms of high-powered competition between strivers for high-profiie careers in finance and government, but rather because of a broad commitment among faculty and students to serious intellectual engagement. The atmosphere of the institution is shaped by the requirement that every student, in their senior year, produce a very substantial senior project under the supervision of a faculty member with expertise in the area chosen by the student. In preparation for this, at the end of two years, all students go through a process called ``moderation'' in which they write a paper reflecting on what they have done and laying out their plans for the next two years. Successful moderation is not guaranteed; the student's major department faculty have to accept the student into the department at this point, which means the faculty commit themselves to mentoring the senior project.

This is not a place where Doonsbury's perpetually clueless undergraduate Zipper Harris would thrive. It is quite different from most institutions, which require students to meet a menu of course requirements but provide little to nothing in the way of independent open-ended academic work. A number of institutions have something similar to the Bard senior project in honors theses, but these are optional, not an intrinsic part of the program, and represent a way to get some Latin superlatives attached to your diploma.

The classes at Bard are very small---there are absolutely no big lecture sections---and students and faculty are on a first-name basis. You can certainly climb and hike a lot and there have been students at Bard who have been very active in these pursuits, but if you are looking for a place to coast through anonymously with minimal involvement while climbing as much as possible, you'd be seriously in the wrong place.

Mike is right about the left-leaning part; the student body and the faculty are generally liberal in their political views and tolerant in terms of life-style choices. I think he is wrong on keeping conservative views in the closet; Bard thrives on debate, right up to the president Leon Botstein, who, for example, engaged in a well-known series of public debates with William Buckley.


FLAG
By kenr
Dec 26, 2012

Bard is near the center of some of the best road bicycling in
the world: northern Dutchess and Columbia counties.

For all those other activities, important to have a car.

Ken


FLAG
By KathyS
From Poughkeepsie, NY
Dec 26, 2012
Me at the summit of Inner Course (5.4) in the Outlets.  Long, lovely, mellow route.  Well protected even.  My favorite lead from the trip.

Look for Fats in the Cats for mt. biking info.


FLAG
By TWK
Dec 26, 2012

Kevin Heckeler wrote:
I know none of my neighbors. Not on purpose, just have no reason to. The internet is great for making friends from anywhere, so I find where I lay my head doesn't matter much.


I don't want to hijack this thread, as Medic741/Matt's questions are important. Also, I'm not bagging on Kevin.

My comments here probably fit better in the MP "Community Forum" section. My apologies.

However . . .

We lived in a solid red semi-rural area for a year, where we barely knew any of neighbors. It really sucked. Unless you went to the same church (which doesn't include the church of "none"), they really didn't have the time of day for you. And I have a lot in common with rednecks.

At great expense and sacrifice, we moved back to where we knew people who had mutual interests and similar political views, and we are very, very happy, and appreciative of what I can only call a sense of community.

The internet, as useful as it may be, is not a real community. No offense intended for those of us who "visit" it. It's a useful enough device to exchange ideas and information, but a neighbor or community it is not.


FLAG
By Medic741
From Pittsford, New York
Dec 26, 2012
When I was a bum at Frey

+1 twk. Everything I've heard has been really good and it's good hearing the perspectives from local climbers. As it looks like ill be probably landing there next year anyone game for a new partner?


FLAG
By Kevin Heckeler
From West Sand Lake, New York
Dec 27, 2012
Rumney

TWK, I was referring to the friends I make who share my interests, which are a low percentage of the overall population (climbers represent less than 1% of humans). The internet is a logical place to find climbers rather than having to shuffle through endless church/social gatherings or rely on random collisions of fate to meet climbers. It helps increase the odds of the less than 1% chance.

My life revolves around human powered activities, not humans. [no church, mall crawling on weekends, drunken fri/sat evenings at the sports bar, etc] I think a college age young adult with an interest in the outdoors can do fine in a room full of rednecks as long as he knows the room next door, with the climbing wall, is occupied with like minded rednecks.

No bagging on you either. Our views on society and life are likely very different.


FLAG
By tradjunkie
Dec 27, 2012

Two further footnotes.

First, RG knows of which he speaks. His professional background makes his perspective on Bard quite meaningful.

Second, nobody here has mentioned options to the east, as there is some latent New York State bias here. To the east of Bard you will find the Taconic range, which may not compare to the Gunks or Adirondacks, but is a nice place worth noting. You'll find worthwhile mellow hiking, biking, and maybe even a bit of rock climbing and caving, across the border area around New York and Connecticut / Massachusetts (and even to Vermont, if you care).


FLAG
By Kevin Heckeler
From West Sand Lake, New York
Dec 27, 2012
Rumney

There's no rock climbing in the Taconics. You have to hit central Mass or CT for rock to the east. No bias, just reality -- drive 90 minutes from Bard to Central Mass, or 60 minutes (probably 45 min) to the Gunks. I've heard some of the climbing in CT is good though, so depending on the drive time that might be an option for him. But I can't imagine it rivals the Gunks, and I don't think it's less than an hour away. I know one of my climbing friends lives in CT and chooses the extra drive to the Gunks.


FLAG
By Gunkiemike
Dec 27, 2012

Thanks for the clarification(s) rg! To show how ill-informed I am, I thought Doonesbury's Walden was fictitious. I apologize to Bard if my comments came off as implying a lack of academic rigor; I was only trying to give an outsider's view of the social/political climate up there.

Kevin, I'm pretty sure that 1.5 hr drive from Bard would leave one an hour or more away from ADK climbing. It's gotta be close to an hour just to get to Albany from there. I know, I'm splitting hairs; once you're on the road you just keep going til you get there.


FLAG
By Kevin Heckeler
From West Sand Lake, New York
Dec 27, 2012
Rumney

Gunkiemike wrote:
Kevin, I'm pretty sure that 1.5 hr drive from Bard would leave one an hour or more away from ADK climbing. It's gotta be close to an hour just to get to Albany from there. I know, I'm splitting hairs; once you're on the road you just keep going til you get there.


You're right Mike, I thought it was further north. According to google maps it's about 2 hours to closest southern ADK crags.


FLAG
By kenr
Dec 27, 2012

tradjunkie wrote:
nobody here has mentioned options to the east, as there is some latent New York State bias here.

The great road-cycling I mentioned is to the East of Bard College.

No "bias" in that: The road-cycling in the mid-Hudson region of NY state is simply better than the Berkshires, and better than most of Vermont for that matter.

also Climbing: the Gunks are just better, and they happen to be in New York.

also groomed-track Cross-Country Skiing: the Gunks (when they have snow, like right now) are just prettier, and they have great trail networks, and they groom for skating (compare Notchview MA). The only XC place anywhere near Bard college to the east outside NY state, that comes close to comparable NY offerings is Prospect Mt in SW Vermont.

The "bias" is with the New Englanders who imagine that since New York City and the Hudson Valley / I-87 corridor are so superior in obvious non-specialized ways, then it can be assumed that they must be inferior for some specialized concern.
The truth is that the City and the Hudson valley corridor are superior in almost every way - (except Rumney has better sport-climbing, but that's a long way from Bard college).

Ken

P.S. the food is better too.


FLAG
By rgold
From Poughkeepsie, NY
Dec 27, 2012
The traverse out to the Yellow Ridge on the Dogstick Ridge link-up.  Photo by Myriam Bouchard

Gunkiemike wrote:
Thanks for the clarification(s) rg! To show how ill-informed I am, I thought Doonesbury's Walden was fictitious.


Doonsbury's Walden is fictitious, although there is also a real Walden University, www.waldenu.edu. Gary Trudeau's alma mater is Yale, and Walden is supposed to be in Connecticut as well. The institution I described is as Doonsbury presents it, and, as required by satire, there are certainly echoes of reality in Doonsbury's Walden, but one finds them in institutions throughout the country, not simply at any one place and not necessarily at the real Walden U, which appears, by the way, to be particularly vocationally focused.

As to whether the area is a conservative enclave, Dutchess County used to be reliably Republican but no more. Registered Democrats slightly outnumber registered Republicans 64,336 to 56,718, Obama carried Dutchess with 53% of the vote, Democrat Kirsten Gillibrand won the U.S. Senate race with 66% of the vote, and Democrat Sean Mahoney beat incumbent Tea Party favorite Nan Hayworth with 54% of the vote. This is not to say that there is not a significant, active, and vocal conservative presence in Dutchess, but we ain't exactly a red state either.


FLAG
By TWK
Dec 28, 2012

kenr wrote:
The only XC place anywhere near Bard college to the east outside NY state, that comes close to comparable NY offerings is Prospect Mt in SW Vermont.


We used to XC ski in NW Mass near Billsville (Williamstown) at a trail network referred to locally as Stone Hill. Don't know its current status, but it sure was good BITD. Worth looking into.

78 miles from Annandale.


FLAG
By Kevin Heckeler
From West Sand Lake, New York
Dec 28, 2012
Rumney

TWK wrote:
We used to XC ski in NW Mass near Billsville (Williamstown) at a trail network referred to locally as Stone Hill. Don't know its current status, but it sure was good BITD. Worth looking into. 78 miles from Annandale.


www.trails.com/tcatalog_trail.aspx?trailid=XAC025-006

Says it's 2.3 miles of trail. That doesn't seem like much to me. (I'm new to x-ski so maybe 2.3 miles is a lot?)

We have better options nearer to us just south (Schodak Island (State Park)). Free during the winter with numerous loops that can push 5+ miles of easy trail if done creatively. Very popular among local skiers, but hardly a destination. And there's numerous places and options like this all over New York State. I see there's a definite bias AGAINST New York! lol


FLAG

Page 1 of 1.