First, I didn't lead this route. I did, however, climb it. It's located on "Hound Rock"--the left side. One can see an arching crack--right to left-- near the top of the formation. Climb the obvious vertical crack and follow the arch. The guide book (Bartlett) rates the route at 5.10d/11a. My partner and I agreed it was closer to 5.10b/c.
Crescent Wrench is definitely 10d on lead. This is a perfect example of why route ratings based on a TR ascent are irrelevant when compared to the difficulty of an onsight attempt on lead.
By Chris Miller Administrator Apr 21, 2005 rating: 5.10d
Short but engaging, especially if lead. Two stars out of five.
The lead vs. toprope rating debate is more suited towards crack climbs IMO; there seems to be little difference between leading and toproping a sport climb.
I again have to agree totally with CM on this one. Leading "Crack/trad" as opposed to top roping crack/trad is a totally different story. On top rope a 10a can feel pretty easy. That same crack on lead depending upon your head/focus at the time of the lead, can feel 10a or like holy hell and 11.oh shit! The same route done three times over a years period can also bring mixed results. That I think is one of the joys of trad...........