By j fassett From tucson Jan 18, 2008
| Kirra,
I didn't start the Sheepshead thread, so I could care less where it goes, however, I did start the rescue thread because I wanted to get some well thought insight on that topic. No offence, I just don't want to see that thread get hijacked.
JF |  |
By Jimbo Jan 19, 2008
| Years ago Dean Brault and I climbed Peacemaker in 1.5 hours pack to pack. I'm not bragging about how fast we climbed. We did, however, get to the base of the climb by 8:30 AM. The point being, we knew we could do it quickly and we still got there early!!!! Then we went over to Mutton Head and did a bunch of the 3 pitch sport routes on that formation. We were going to do another but it was getting close to sundown so we didn't. The end result no rapping in the dark or anything. Imagine that.
|  |
By Russ Walling From www.FishProducts.com Jan 20, 2008
| kirra wrote: Cochise is definitely one place to get an early start.
Nope. Start time is usually skill dependent. Slugs with full packs, water bladders, and anti_bonking Goo™™ should get an early start. For the rest of us, experience should be your guide as to start time. |  |
By Braxton Norwood From Tucson Jan 20, 2008
| I think the page here will have some details about 'The Sheepshead Incident' in the next month or so. I have to post this quote from the January 2008 Newsletter, though, as it's pretty much hilarious:
Sun, 09 Dec Missing hiker Ventana Canyon, Catalinas 14:27 – 14:52 A hiker with a twisted ankle was assisted out by a SARA member, who reported a missing companion. Meanwhile, she returned from a visit to the ladies room.
On an unrelated note, there are some climbing gyms in Euroland that have zero permanent topropes (Arco, Italy has one). That's right, all climbs must be done on lead (routes can then be TR'd through the "anchor"). If you don't lead, or climb with somebody who does, you don't climb. Maybe that'd help with the false sense of security people get after successfully TRing a handful of 30' 5.8s indoors, on plastic holds, with color-taped routes, in a climate-controlled environment, etc... |  |
By Marc Horan From Lafayette, CO Jan 21, 2008
| When I first started climbing, I did not receive any formal training. I bought some gear (cheap--from a shop I was working at) and went and figured it out for myself (with a couple friends).
Because of this lack of training, I endured some unnecessary epics. I learned a lot from these epics. That's why I'm still here, 10+ years later, relatively healthy.
I'm sure people laughed at me along the way. To some extent, I'm glad I gave a few people laughs; I probably caused some headaches along the way for other climbers.
Anyway, I'm glad that things turned out the way they did for me. I consider myself a very 'instinctive' climber; when I get in a tight spot, I rely on my instincts to get me out of trouble--and they haven't failed me yet.
Have a chuckle at the expense of the rescued climbers if you will, but they might be sending 5.15s sometime down the line, you never know.
On a side note: If they had to pay for their rescue, I bet they would have thought twice about 1) going up the route under the circumstances that they did, and 2) calling for a rescue vs trying to extricate themselves from the situation. |  |
By Richard Radcliffe From Louisville, CO Jan 21, 2008
| Marc Horan wrote: On a side note: If they had to pay for their rescue, I bet they would have thought twice about 1) going up the route under the circumstances that they did, and 2) calling for a rescue vs trying to extricate themselves from the situation. I'm not so sure about this. I think there are basically two situations in any potential or real rescue situation. If someone is going on a route on which they know they are pushing their limits, they will prepare as best they can to avoid any need for a rescue: carrying a flashlight and extra clothes, paying attention to the weather, etc. The second case is when people are getting in over their heads and don't realize it and so aren't prepared for what the climb throws at them. The former is typically the more experienced climber while the latter tends to be more of a beginner (or just plain stupid/lucky). In either case, I doubt that having to pay for a potential rescue (and knowing it), which is what happens in some areas, would be much of a deterrent. |  |
By Marc Horan From Lafayette, CO Jan 21, 2008
| Richard Radcliffe wrote: I'm not so sure about this. I think there are basically two situations in any potential or real rescue situation. If someone is going on a route on which they know they are pushing their limits, they will prepare as best they can to avoid any need for a rescue: carrying a flashlight and extra clothes, paying attention to the weather, etc. The second case is when people are getting in over their heads and don't realize it and so aren't prepared for what the climb throws at them. The former is typically the more experienced climber while the latter tends to be more of a beginner (or just plain stupid/lucky). In either case, I doubt that having to pay for a potential rescue (and knowing it), which is what happens in some areas, would be much of a deterrent.
I agree that the majority of parties that get rescue assistance don't believe they're going to need it when they set out on their adventure. But I also know that if I had to make a choice between a) calling for rescue b) spending a miserable night out, I would choose the latter every time. Of course there's some amount of pride involved in that decision, but mostly, I would fear putting the members of a SAR team in a (potentially risky) situation that they wouldn't need to be in.
--Marc |  |
By susan peplow From what day is this? Jan 23, 2008
| kirra wrote: experience should be your guide to get a life and stop harassing me what was that...you referred to yourself as a Slug™™ or slimy creature???
The above statement is quoted merely as a reference point. As per usual Kirra comes out swinging even when nothing has been said to her directly. If it's not quoted, she'll delete it. In classic KB™ style.
It's not all about you Kirra, in fact I hadn't seen a single reference directed at you throughout this entire thread until you started with the insults. Some people never learn. |  |
By Flaccid Jan 23, 2008
| Kirra, please stop polluting these important threads. Some of us are trying to learn something of value here. I would like to be able to read what some very experienced people are trying to say, but your injections of weird drama and sniping are making it impossible. Thank you. |  |
By Tradster Jan 23, 2008
| I've looked at these posts for some time on this web site. Kirra, you certainly know how to use personal attacks on everyone. Your demeanor on these threads makes me want to stay off of the various forums. Why don't you try to keep things civil...and perhaps be more mature. |  |
By Larry Jan 23, 2008
| Does MP have a killfile / ignore option? I guess not. |  |
By Geir Hundal From Tucson, AZ Jan 23, 2008
| Russ-
Your posts are some of the funniest things I've read in a long time. Thanks! |  |
By Geir Hundal From Tucson, AZ Jan 24, 2008
| Kirra? Hello?? Your posts disappeared. How strange... |  |
By susan peplow From what day is this? Jan 24, 2008
| Since this thread has drifted away then back then away, I don't feel too bad about this next drift.
Bill Dacier? Many of you may not know this but Bill is a long time AZ climber... interesting that his first post is telling Kirra to stop the babble.
Welcome to Mountain Project Bill. Tell us a story or two would ya? We're dying for something entertaining!
~Susan Debora's Sister (as in Debora & Fernando) |  |
By Larry Apr 24, 2008
| Braxton Norwood wrote: I think the page here will have some details about 'The Sheepshead Incident' in the next month or so.
Umm, nope. No mention. A guy got bucked off his horse in the Catalinas on 12/30 though.
Did Pima County not get called out on this? |  |
|