The belay location is a little treacherous, the first bolt is a little low, and the rock is a little rough. That said I still give it two stars because a few of the moves are really great. Most of the holds are crimps. One of the cruxes was reachy and the other balancey. In my opinion this route is about as hard as a 10 can get without being an 11.
dcohn, I thought about putting the first bolt higher, but if you slipped before getting the clip you and your belayer would tumble down the gully. Someone else also thought 10d would be a fair rating on this one.