slim wrote:i don't really recommend the whole run it out thing at the creek, particularly if you haven't climbed there before. An interesting observation; of the approximately dozen times i have seen gear rip at the creek, it has been multiple pieces. also, i think you will be able to climb more relaxed if the piece is at your knees or feet than you will if you are 10 feet above your last piece. i would be interested to see how many people that recommend running it out actually do so on something other than easy handcracks - i'm guessing not that many.....
I agree with slim here. Running it out may conserve energy if you are a zen master, but that is not the case for the vast majority of us. Most of us start overgripping a bit once we are a body-length out from the last piece, and we really overgrip once that piece is two body lengths away. Plus, gear does rip at the Creek, especially when dealing with smaller pieces. Placing gear at a comfortable distance helps me stay loose and relaxed, and the energy savingas gained here more than make up for the energy spent placing an etra 2-3 pieces over the course of a pitch. This is especially true at the creek, where plugging a piece at waist-to-chest level takes a few seconds, consumes very little energy, and helps you relax a lot better.
On a somewhat related note, on thinner/harder cracks I feel that leading with a nest-and-punch cadence has a lot of benefit. The idea here is that a single small cam isn't sufficiently confifence inspiring to run it out over, but 2 of them together generally do inspire confidence. Even at the Creek, there are spots where you can relax a bit (due to an edge that provides a foothold, or a slight pod that allows a better jam, etc). At these places, instead of placing just once piece, place 2 of them, spaced a few feet apart. This gives you a little nest of gear to keep you safe as you punch it through the hard section to get to the next stance/pod/pausing point. This strategy seems touse less energy than placing single pieces at greater frequency, but feels a lot safer than punching it above a single blue metolius.
I'm not sure that this strategy has much place on 5.10 hand cracks, since a single #2 is basically an anchor, making the nesting strategy unnneccesary. Also, I think that most 5.10 trad leaders try to climb too fast anyway. Oftentimes, climbers at this level have not yet learned how to relax and rest while hanging on their arms on steep terrain. When they start to get pumped, they panic slightly and try to climb faster, placing less gear, climbing with less control, and trying to race the pump to the anchor. We see this all the time. It is much better to learn to slow down a bit, catch your breath, and rest. There is absolutely no reason to get even the slightest bit pumped on an Indian Creek hand crack; the whole route is one bit resting opprotunity. If I tried to climb a 100 foot steep hand crack without stopping, I know that I'd get pumped. It is mcuh better to climb efficiently for 10 feet, then pause, beathe, find a restful body position, place a piece, relax a bit, and then start moving again. At this cadence, you won't get pumped, you won't panic, and you can place plenty of gear.