Login with Facebook
 ADVANCED
Roger's Roof on a cool September afternoon
Id# 105868653, 1600 x 1200px View full size
Comments on Photo Add Comment
By Jay Knower
Administrator
From: Campton, NH
Oct 4, 2006
Wow. This is a great picture of a great route. Hardest 5.8 in the park.
By James M Schroeder
From: Sauk County, WI
Apr 24, 2007
No way is this the hardest 5.8 in the park. Impossible Crack is harder, either of the Lost Face Roofs are harder, etc. Just cause you have tiny hands and tiny feet Jay...
By Tony B
From: Around Boulder, CO
Apr 25, 2007
For a brief moment of time, I thought 'Cesarean Tower' was the hardest 5.8 in the park (and the world)... until the massive convulsing fits of laughter from the crowd tipped me off and someone finally told me that I'd been sandbagged by my 'local' partner onto Cesarean Direct.
By Jay Knower
Administrator
From: Campton, NH
Apr 25, 2007
That's really funny Tony.
By Peter Arndt
Aug 20, 2008
Have not climbed every 5.8 in the park but I would echo Jay on this one.
Very hard indeed for the grade. The Bible errrrrrr Swartling's guide cites RR as a benchmark for the 5.8 grade at DL.
By Nick Adams
From: Delafield, WI
Aug 10, 2009
RR feels more comfortable to me than either of the 3 routes below, which I have only seconded and I'm still gunning to lead:

1) Chicago (leadable and pretty well protected if you find the right placements), also very sustained to the top.

2) Britton's Direct

3) Jolly Roger

I think any of these are DL 5.8 benchmark material - as well. But to date I'm only a 2nd on these climbs so I'll defer to those who've led 'em.

Thoughts?
By Isaac Therneau
From: Rochester, MN
Aug 10, 2009
It felt comfortable when I onsighted it on lead, but then when I came back with a TR I barely thrutched over the roof without falling. Some of these climbs can change drastically if you happen to miss a single foot/hand hold or mess up the sequence.
By Tony B
From: Around Boulder, CO
Aug 10, 2009
I was talking with Roger on Friday and he was saying that Jim Ericson was saying that it was probably the harderst 5.8 there in the day, and one of the harderst 5.8 cracks in the country at it's time. Just another opinion (YMMV), but one with some bredth of experience.
By Ryan Strong
From: Golden, CO
Jun 19, 2011
i have led all of these routes and here goes my list in order of hardest 5.8

1. Chicago
2. Lost Face Overhangs
3. Brinton's Direct

Have not done impossible crack yet, but i imagine its up there!
Photo 3 of 12
Avg Score   5.0 from 10 votes
Your Score   

Roger's Roof on a cool September afternoon

Submitted By: Ian Schmit on Oct 4, 2006
On this route:
Roger's Roof (5.8 5b 16 VI- 15 HVS 4c )
 Printer View